Can I Use HP Sauce Instead of BBQ Sauce?

When it comes to barbecue sauces, there are countless variations available on the market. One popular sauce that often comes up in discussions is HP Sauce.

If you find yourself wondering whether you can use HP Sauce as a substitute for BBQ sauce, this article will shed some light on the topic.

What is HP Sauce?

HP Sauce is a tangy and savory condiment that originated in the United Kingdom. It has a unique flavor profile, combining ingredients like tomatoes, vinegar, molasses, and a blend of spices.

While it is not specifically designed to be used as a barbecue sauce, many people have found ways to incorporate it into their grilling recipes.

Differences Between HP Sauce and BBQ Sauce

The main difference between HP Sauce and traditional BBQ sauce lies in their flavor profiles. Barbecue sauces typically have a sweet and smoky taste with hints of acidity and heat.

On the other hand, HP Sauce has a tangier and more savory flavor with its own distinct blend of spices.


BBQ sauces often have a thick consistency that clings to meat when applied during cooking or as a finishing glaze. In contrast, HP Sauce has a thinner texture similar to that of ketchup or Worcestershire sauce.


While BBQ sauce is specifically formulated for grilling and smoking meats, HP Sauce has traditionally been used as a condiment for dishes such as steak pies, bacon sandwiches, or fried breakfasts. However, its versatility allows it to be used creatively in various recipes.

Using HP Sauce as an Alternative to BBQ Sauce

If you find yourself without BBQ sauce but have HP Sauce on hand, you can certainly use it as an alternative. However, it’s important to note that the resulting flavor may differ from what you would achieve with a traditional BBQ sauce.

When substituting HP Sauce for BBQ sauce, consider adjusting other ingredients in your recipe to balance the flavors. For example, you might want to add a touch of sweetness by incorporating honey or brown sugar.

Additionally, if the recipe calls for heat or smokiness, you can experiment with adding spices like paprika or chili powder.

Recipes Using HP Sauce Instead of BBQ Sauce

While using HP Sauce as a substitute for BBQ sauce may not provide an exact replication of flavors, it can still add a unique twist to your dishes. Here are a few ideas to get you started:

  • Marinate pork chops in a mixture of HP Sauce, honey, and garlic before grilling them.
  • Add HP Sauce to meatloaf mixtures for an extra tangy kick.
  • Brush HP Sauce onto chicken wings during the last few minutes of grilling to create a flavorful glaze.
  • Create a homemade burger sauce by mixing mayonnaise, ketchup, mustard, and HP Sauce.

Remember that experimenting with flavors is part of the fun when it comes to cooking. While using HP Sauce as a substitute for BBQ sauce may not always yield the same result, it can still be an enjoyable way to explore new taste combinations.


In summary, while there are some differences between HP Sauce and traditional BBQ sauce in terms of flavor profile and texture, you can certainly use HP Sauce as an alternative if needed. Just be prepared for some variation in taste and consider adjusting other ingredients to balance the flavors.

So go ahead and get creative in the kitchen with HP Sauce – you might just discover a new favorite recipe!